Saturday, October 30, 2004
Bin Quarterbacking
Prefatory gripe: I'm not a sports fan. As such, I could really wish for a 72-hour moratorium on sports metaphors. (I'll see the sun rise in the west, first.) Predictably, however, the bin Laden tape is bringing them to the fore:
"He didn't choose to use American forces to hunt down Osama bin Laden,'' Kerry told WISN in Milwaukee. "He outsourced the job.''
Bush responded, "It's the worst kind of Monday-morning quarterbacking,'' and quoted his Afghan war commander, the now-retired Gen. Tommy Franks, as saying intelligence reports at the time were unclear about bin Laden's whereabouts.
Okay, Monday morning quarterbacking can be a legitimate criticism. But if a team's coach and quarterback decide — all codpiece resolutely like — to run toward the wrong goal post and someone notices, is that someone a Monday morning quarterback?
Side question to Tommy bin Looking for a Sinecure: short of having a GPS transponder attached to bin Laden's back, is it easier to hunt down a fugitive within a hundred square miles, or ten thousand square miles three years later?
Just asking.
posted by Glen |
9:42 AM |
Friday, October 29, 2004
Osama
Wasn't he supposed to be dead or something?
I know how Republicans will spin it, but it really does put the lie to George's contention that bin Laden isn't important. He's alive, well, and still able to rally the faithful.
Post-publication note:
One snark can provoke another. Some hours ago, Matt wrote:
How could you even consider switching horses in midstream when the incumbent is a steadfast leader who delivers on all his promises. I'm sure bin Laden will be found "dead or alive" one of the days now, perhaps sometime in the second Jeb administration.
Osama is also useful to rally our faithful, too — as a boogeyman. Why the hell would George (or Jeb) want him captured or killed? Is that the explanation behind Tora Bora?
posted by Glen |
6:42 PM |
100,000
I don't know whether I'm the last blogger to see this, but I feel sick. Jesus.
More than 100,000 civilians have probably died as direct or indirect consequences of the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq, according to a study by a research team at Johns Hopkins University's Bloomberg School of Public Health in Baltimore.
The report was published on the Internet by The Lancet, the British medical journal. The figure is far higher than previous mortality estimates. Editors of the journal decided not to wait for The Lancet's normal publication date next week, but instead to place the research online Friday, apparently so it could circulate before the U.S. presidential election.
The finding is certain to generate intense controversy, since the Bush administration has not estimated civilian casualties from the conflict, and independent groups have put the number at most in the tens of thousands.
In the study, teams of researchers fanned out across Iraq in mid-September to interview nearly 1,000 families in 33 previously selected locations. Families were interviewed about births and deaths in the household before and after the invasion.
Although the paper's authors acknowledge that thorough data collection was difficult in what is effectively still a war zone, the data they managed to collect are extensive: Iraqis were 2.5 times more likely to die in the 17 months following the invasion than in the 14 months before it. Before the invasion, the most common causes of death in Iraq were heart attacks, strokes and chronic diseases. Afterward, violent death was far ahead of all other causes.
"We were shocked at the magnitude but we're quite sure that the estimate of 100,000 is a conservative estimate," said Dr. Gilbert Burnham of the Johns Hopkins study team. He said the team had excluded deaths in Falluja in making their estimate, since that city was the site of unusually intense violence.
In 15 of the 33 communities visited, residents reported violent deaths in the family since the conflict started in March 2003. They attributed many of those deaths to attacks by coalition forces - mostly airstrikes - and most of the reported deaths were of women and children.
The risk of violent death was 58 times higher than before the war, the researchers found.
"The fact that more than half of the deaths caused by the occupation forces were women and children is a cause for concern," the authors wrote.
The team included researchers from the Johns Hopkins Center for International Emergency, Disaster and Refugee Studies as well as doctors from Al Mustansiriya University Medical School in Baghdad.
There is bound to be skepticism about the estimate of 100,000 excess deaths, which translates into an average of 166 excess deaths a day since the invasion. But some were not surprised.
"I am emotionally shocked, but I have no trouble in believing that this many people have been killed," said Scott Lipscomb, an associate professor at Northwestern University.
.
Lipscomb works on a Web site called www.iraqbodycount.net. That project, which collates only media-reported deaths, currently puts the death toll at just under 17,000. "We've always maintained that the actual count must be much higher," Lipscomb said.
I haven't seen the report itself. (I'll tangle with the registration later.) The Lancet is an old, very reputable medical journal; I'm acquainted with it from my days as a medical editor. If they are confident enough to publish the report, I'm alarmed. The toll rivals the obscene slaughter in Sudan and Saddam's put down of the Shia rebellion after the Gulf War.
A prediction: the usual suspects will focus on The Lancet's decision to release the report ahead of its normal schedule as a politically motivated act, and they will try their damnedest to ignore the report itself. After all, in an election voters should not base their decisions on unpleasant facts. Anyone who tries to do so is obviously playing politics. As noted in the article, the Bush administration has pointedly not estimated civilian deaths during this God damned war. That's called "principle."
One hundred thousand deaths in 18 months.
posted by Glen |
1:24 PM |
Mary Cheney, Mary Cheney
Via John at By the Bayou, Concerned Women for America is using Mary Cheney for political purposes. The author of the piece is Regina Griggs.
I am the parent of a homosexual child and the executive director of Parents and Friends of Ex-Gays and Gays (PFOX), a national organization that offers support and education to families and friends of homosexuals, and advocates for the rights of ex-gays.
I didn't realize that ex-gays were rights impaired. They can't marry?
I look forward to Lynne and Dick's "inner angry parent" to rise up and denounce Griggs for exploiting their daughter.
posted by Glen |
7:50 AM |
Thursday, October 28, 2004
How Low Can They Go?
I didn't know this:
The worst attack ads in this billion-dollar year of tooth-and-claw politicking leave voters poised somewhere between anger (How could they sink so low?) and hilarity (Do they really think we're that dumb?). It's a bumper crop, and we're not even talking about the lame resort to animal tableaux by the Bush campaign (terrorists as wolves) and Kerry partisans (a soaring eagle versus a head-in-the-sand ostrich). No, if they gave awards for intelligence-insulting attack ads - let's call the statuettes the Simpletons - this year's finalists would include one demeaning Terry Anderson, a Democratic candidate for the Ohio Legislature, with a photograph of him next to a Hezbollah terrorist.
Mr. Anderson is understandably furious: he was actually kidnapped in Lebanon and chained for nearly seven years by Hezbollah thugs. He later returned as a free man to confront one of his captors, a moment that now turns up in the ludicrous flier depicting Mr. Anderson as soft on terrorism.
In other words, Max Cleland all over again, this time in Ohio.
My contempt knows no bounds.
posted by Glen |
11:41 AM |
Wednesday, October 27, 2004
Shorter George Bush
How dare you make an issue out of my screw-ups!
posted by Glen |
2:31 PM |
Tuesday, October 26, 2004
Foreknowledge
During the debates, Kerry was criticized for saying the war cost $200 billion. Not so! It's "only" $120 billion, pundits cried. (At the time, Cost of War put in the mid $130 billion range, but what's a few billion among friends?)
It seems Kerry wasn't wrong, just right prematurely:
Increase in War Funding Sought
Bush to Request $70 Billion More
Who in the reality-based community didn't see it coming?
posted by Glen |
2:39 PM |
More of the Good News
The massacre of the Iraqi police cadets during the weekend was horrifying. But story gets worse.
The massacre of 50 unarmed Iraqi cadets headed home on leave suggests Iraqi insurgents have infiltrated Iraq's security forces deeply enough to gain intelligence and make precision strikes of their own.
Although U.S. officials say it's too early to tell whether the cadets were set up, some American officers have long regarded Iraq's security forces as susceptible to infiltration. Last week, defense officials in Washington described Iraq's security forces as ''heavily infiltrated'' by insurgents.
Ya think? But not to worry: the January elections will go off on time and with nary a hitch. We create reality, remember? But there's more.
At Abu Ghraib prison, Iraqi guards gave maps of the prison to inmates who wanted to escape and smuggled in drugs and weapons, including a handgun given to a prisoner who engaged in a shootout with U.S. troops, Brig. Gen. Janis Karpinski, who was once in charge of the prison, said in an e-mail interview Monday.
The U.S.-led occupation authority ''simply bypassed the vetting process,'' said Karpinski, who was relieved of her command after prisoner abuses at the prison came to light.
Karpinski said she suspects two car bombings next to the prison were done with help from Iraqi guards, many of whom disappeared as soon as they were given weapons.
I have a hard time regarding Karpinski as a poor little lamb. Her failings, however, do not deflect, excuse, or exonerate the massive screw-ups that have plagued George and Don's Excellent Adventure from the get-go.
Yep, we're creating reality (a/k/a making shit up) as we go along. And look at it.
posted by Glen |
7:12 AM |
Monday, October 25, 2004
I'll Say Anything
Bush is appealing to Democrats on national security grounds, citing FDR and Truman. Had either of them fought a war as incompetently as this one, we'd be speaking German on the East Coast and Japanese on the West. Or Russian from sea to shining sea.
posted by Glen |
6:44 PM |
Let the Brazening Begin
Via Josh Marshall, I see that special brand of brazenness we all love so well is kicking into gear:
The Bush campaign dismissed Mr Kerry's criticism, without responding to the allegations. "John Kerry has no vision for fighting and winning the War on Terror, so he is basing his attacks on the headlines he wakes up to each day," said a campaign spokesman, Steve Schmidt.
God damn it, this headline is not about a dip in the Dow or dissing Poland. It's the most serious security breach in this whole bloody affair. If George wants Kerry to stop basing attacks on headlines, maybe he should stop creating so many of them.
posted by Glen |
1:16 PM |
The Worst Failure Yet: A Follow-Up
George originally justified the war on the basis of WMDs. Here was a facility in which the closest things to WMDs were being stored. The facility's location was precisely known. The IAEA provided an inventory. And George & Co. did nothing. And they're still doing nothing: as the Times article makes clear, whatever of value left in that installation was still being carried out the door as of yesterday.
George has now lost the last shred of credibility on the last issue he could possibly claim: the safety and security of the United States.
Consider what the "Wright Brothers' evil twins," McVeigh and Nichols, did in Oklahoma City and what they used. Now start multiplying. Now factor in the detail that their fertilizer-based bomb was large and clumsy, while the missing explosives are small, easily disguised, and exponentially more powerful. Tankers glide in and out of ports uninspected. Cargo planes sit unsecured. Picture the next Lockerbie above New York or Chicago or Los Angeles.
And while we're at it, just how much of these horrors are already being used against Americans and Iraqis alike right this minute?
Recovering Bushoholic, Andrew Sullivan called this massive failure "criminal negligence." For once we are in agreement. At the very least, there should be a boatload of summary terminations, beginning in the White House and ending in Baghdad. Better: there should be a boatload of prosecutions. But I have no doubt that George & Co. will try to brazen it out.
It's hard to wrap your mind around just how much damage has been done in a little less than four years. Deficits as far as the eye can see, being layered on to more than $7 trillion dollars of debt. An unnecessary war with thousands dead and thousands more maimed. And now we've inflamed and radicalized people who distrusted or despised us before, and armed them, too.
Actually, criminal negligence may be praise by faint damnation.
It's a shame that the Founders did not include negligence or incompetence among the grounds for impeachment. But, then, they were optimists. They never conceived of a George W. Bush.
posted by Glen |
12:28 PM |
The Worst Failure Yet
The next time Bush says that he "knows" how to conduct the war on terror, someone should cram this article down his throat, physically.
BAGHDAD, Iraq, Oct. 24 - The Iraqi interim government has warned the United States and international nuclear inspectors that nearly 380 tons of powerful conventional explosives - used to demolish buildings, make missile warheads and detonate nuclear weapons - are missing from one of Iraq's most sensitive former military installations.
The huge facility, called Al Qaqaa, was supposed to be under American military control but is now a no man's land, still picked over by looters as recently as Sunday. United Nations weapons inspectors had monitored the explosives for many years, but White House and Pentagon officials acknowledge that the explosives vanished sometime after the American-led invasion last year.
The White House said President Bush's national security adviser, Condoleezza Rice, was informed within the past month that the explosives were missing. It is unclear whether President Bush was informed. American officials have never publicly announced the disappearance, but beginning last week they answered questions about it posed by The New York Times and the CBS News program "60 Minutes."
Administration officials said Sunday that the Iraq Survey Group, the C.I.A. task force that searched for unconventional weapons, has been ordered to investigate the disappearance of the explosives.
American weapons experts say their immediate concern is that the explosives could be used in major bombing attacks against American or Iraqi forces: the explosives, mainly HMX and RDX, could produce bombs strong enough to shatter airplanes or tear apart buildings.
The bomb that brought down Pan Am Flight 103 over Lockerbie, Scotland, in 1988 used less than a pound of the same type of material, and larger amounts were apparently used in the bombing of a housing complex in November 2003 in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, and the blasts in a Moscow apartment complex in September 1999 that killed nearly 300 people.
The explosives could also be used to trigger a nuclear weapon, which was why international nuclear inspectors had kept a watch on the material, and even sealed and locked some of it. The other components of an atom bomb - the design and the radioactive fuel - are more difficult to obtain.
[...]
The International Atomic Energy Agency publicly warned about the danger of these explosives before the war, and after the invasion it specifically told United States officials about the need to keep the explosives secured, European diplomats said in interviews last week. Administration officials say they cannot explain why the explosives were not safeguarded, beyond the fact that the occupation force was overwhelmed by the amount of munitions they found throughout the country.
[...]
The Qaqaa facility, about 30 miles south of Baghdad, was well known to American intelligence officials: Mr. Hussein made conventional warheads at the site, and the I.A.E.A. dismantled parts of his nuclear program there in the early 1990's after the Persian Gulf war in 1991. In the prelude to the 2003 invasion, Mr. Bush cited a number of other "dual use" items - including tubes that the administration contended could be converted to use for the nuclear program - as a justification for invading Iraq.
[...]
A special property of HMX and RDX lends them to smuggling and terrorism, experts said. While violently energetic when detonated, they are insensitive to shock and physical abuse during handling and transport because of their chemical stability. A hammer blow does nothing. It takes a detonator, like a blasting cap, to release the stored energy.
Experts said the insensitivity made them safer to transport than the millions of unexploded shells, mines and pieces of live ammunition that litter Iraq. And its benign appearance makes it easy to disguise as harmless goods, easily slipped across borders. [Emphases added]
Sorry for the long extract, but it's important. A copy of the IAEA's notice is here.
Remember Donny Rumsfeld's cavalier remark about democracy being "untidy"? Well, 380 tons of "untidiness" are now loose in the world. Among the U.S. officials warned was Jerry Bremer. But he was too busy transforming the Iraqi economy into a neocon paradise. The Iraq Survey Group has been ordered to "investigate" the explosives' disappearance, about 18 months after the horse left the barn. A common truck can carry ten tons of them.
George and his crack team of "rose petal experts" have armed unknown radicals all over the planet. Whatever Saddam's wet dreams, this stuff was in place and guarded. But the world is safer now that he's in jail, right?
Right. Damn fine job, guys.
I can't even begin to count how many nightmare scenarios I can construct. Buildings. Bridges. Tunnels. Oil pipelines. Refineries. Nuclear power plants. Chemical plants. Liquid natural gas storage facilities. LNG tankers. Dams. Not just in the United States: anywhere in the world. Nice Chunnel you have there, Mr. Blair. It would be a shame if you lost it.
I thought this war was the worst mistake we could make. I was wrong. The execution is.
Is we safer?
posted by Glen |
8:34 AM |
Sunday, October 24, 2004
Superqueers
Via Andrew Sullivan, a visit to that other community:
Taking a hard line against ads run by Democrat Brad Carson's campaign for the U.S. Senate against Republican candidate Tom Coburn, well-known Focus on the Family founder James Dobson said Friday, "It's wrong. It's evil."
Dobson, who had been stumping for Coburn in Oklahoma since Thursday, said Carson was lying.
"He may very well be a nice man, and I'm not attacking his personhood, but there's a gap between who he says he is and what he does," Dobson said, criticizing Carson for votes on partial-birth abortion and in support of same-sex marriage.
Dobson warned those attending the Friday afternoon rally at Oklahoma Christian University that the sanctity of marriage between a man and a woman must be protected.
He cited examples of countries such as Norway that have allowed same-sex couples to marry as proof that fewer men and women get married.
Dobson said 80 percent of children are born out of wedlock in Norway.
"Homosexuals are not monogamous. They want to destroy the institution of marriage," Dobson said.
"It will destroy marriage. It will destroy the Earth."
I had no idea we were so powerful. If not for the Republicans' secret supply of lavender Kryptonite....
As Andrew noted, Dobson is "one of the most influential people in the Republican Party." On November 2nd, it's not just possibly electing George: he brings with him a passel of village idiots from all over the country. Does anyone want to keep this one in Washington?
By the way, just as a reality check, Carson voted for the Federal Marriage Amendment. Dobson may feel free to play fast and loose with the Ten Commandments (especially one of them), but he should really get acquainted with the Eleventh: Thou Shalt Google. It took 0.25 seconds.
posted by Glen |
7:48 PM |
Wolves
I've seen the Attack of the Puppies ad. I've seen the disclaimer from Wolfpacks for Truth,who were told the human pack arriving in Humvees were filming a Greenpeace commercial. And I've read how Tom Ridge put New York City (and others) into a major Duct Tape and Cover alert in July because of threats to the election, followed by "Oops, never mind".
Please tell me I'm not the only one to come up with the obvious: The Administration That Cried Wolf.
Over and over and over and over and over....
posted by Glen |
4:00 PM |
Spyware
Some relief for spyware sufferers:
A federal judge has ordered a man known as the "Spam King" to disable so-called spyware programs that infiltrate people's computers, track their Internet use and flood them with pop-up advertising.
U.S. District Judge Joseph DiClerico issued a temporary restraining order Thursday against Stanford Wallace and his companies, SmartBot.net Inc. of Richboro, Pa., and Seismic Entertainment Productions Inc. of Rochester. SmartBot's principal place of business is Barrington.
Prosecutors sought the injunction on behalf of the Federal Trade Commission, which targeted Wallace in its first anti-spyware action.
The judge ordered Wallace to remove software code that exploits security holes in computer operating systems and Web browsers, then tracks people's Internet use to bombard them with pop-up ads.
[...]
Wallace also is accused of trying to sell computer users $30 remedies called "Spy Wiper" and "Spy Deleter" that the FTC says don't work.
Excellent. Not just extortion but extortion with no promise that your payoff will actually buy anything. Sort of like paying protection money and watching your store get trashed again anyway — by the very same thugs you just handed small, unmarked bills. And they'll be back again, tomorrow.
Not being that technologically knowledgeable, I'll be interested to see how this is accomplished. Will Wallace's noxious products receive messages from "home base" (for lack of a better term), telling them to delete themselves? How will anyone know that they have has not just turned themselves off until the legal case is resolved? I hope district attorneys' technical offices are getting the funding necessary to hire some really savvy people.
From a legal standpoint, can Wallace pop up (pun intended) with a different company that does the same thing, but which is incorporated in, say, Bulgaria or Nigeria where laws are lax and U.S. prosecutors can't reach them? In the past, more traditional "fly-by-nighters" have evaded the law by just jumping from state to state. Much as I love the internet, it really does have a Dark Side.
With a superstitious knock on wood, I haven't tangled with Wallace's Invaders, which by all accounts are more relentless than the Borg. On the recommendation of a co-worker, I downloaded the free, personal version of Ad-Aware (shameless plug), plus new definitions every few weeks. So far, I've found more than 500 in about two months. When she downloaded the software, she found more than 600 in the first night.
posted by Glen |
11:22 AM |
Saturday, October 23, 2004
Keeping Democracy Safe from Machines
John at By the Bayou received a link to a clever video about a voting machine that won't let a guy cast a vote for Kerry. I looked at it last night. It's clever, well done, and I laughed.
Well, I ain't laughing anymore.
From G.D. Frogsdong (who found it at Suburban Guerrilla), it's really happening, and too much like John's video:
Kim Griffith voted on Thursday— over and over and over.
She's among the people in Bernalillo and Sandoval counties who say they have had trouble with early voting equipment. When they have tried to vote for a particular candidate, the touch-screen system has said they voted for somebody else.
[...]
She went to Valle Del Norte Community Center in Albuquerque, planning to vote for John Kerry. "I pushed his name, but a green check mark appeared before President Bush's name," she said.
Griffith erased the vote by touching the check mark at Bush's name. That's how a voter can alter a touch-screen ballot.
She again tried to vote for Kerry, but the screen again said she had voted for Bush. The third time, the screen agreed that her vote should go to Kerry.
She faced the same problem repeatedly as she filled out the rest of the ballot. On one item, "I had to vote five or six times," she said.
Michael Cadigan, president of the Albuquerque City Council, had a similar experience when he voted at City Hall.
"I cast my vote for president. I voted for Kerry and a check mark for Bush appeared," he said.
[...]
Bernalillo County Clerk Mary Herrera said she doesn't believe the touch-screen system has been making mistakes. It's the fault of voters, she said Thursday. Of course it is, dearie. And how many people use ATMs three times a week without sending their money into oblivion? Suddenly, those very same people get completely stupid when confronted with what is essentially a larger scale ATM?
Just to make sure that everyone understands: the same article noted that people who tried to vote for Bush found themselves voting for Kerry. For what it's worth, it was a non-partisan glitch; I don't think makes it better.
These stories are surfacing too often. In a "just do it" rush to avoid another Florida, we may be turning a big chunk of the nation into Florida. Two months ago, Bruce Garrett, who designs software for the team that keeps the Hubble Telescope in orbit, yelled,
Let's hear it for paper trails. No...wait...let's hear it for paper ballots. I'm serious. ... Listen to me: there should never be software anywhere in the path between the person who casts a vote and the people who tally all the votes. Anywhere. Anywhere. Did you get that? Anywhere. [Emphasis in the original.]
No doubt prompted by John's offering, I thought about Bruce's recommendation again last night: all paper all the time, like Canada. I agree. Pragmatically, however, it probably wouldn't fly here: unlike Canada, we are the nation of instant gratification. So how about something somewhere in between?
In the November issue of Harper's (not yet on-line), Greg Palast noted that optical scanners have a 0.1% error rate, compared with 1% for touch-screen machines. (Taxpayer frugally, the optical scanners also cost one-eighth as much; but I digress.) Hence, the compromise: all optical-scan voting machines. Instead of a receipt, which could be manipulated by printing one thing while the machine recorded something else (thus leaving the unwary unwary and the dishonest gleeful), the machines can't count the votes without hands-on-paper ballots. The machines, however, would be used to tally only the preliminary results. As soon as the polls close, the paper ballots are counted again, manually, automatically. The key point is, the results are not official until the ballots are hand counted. Almost instant results and mandatory verifications are combined. In a conflict between paper and machines, paper wins.
(Parenthetically, I don't work with computers at nearly the same level as Bruce: I manage databases; I don't design the underlying software. But I know, bitterly, that double checking and physical back ups are good when the computers produce GIGO. Moreover, and uncynically for once, things just happen. I'm also involved in "disaster recovery" planning at work, so I have had to think about things beyond human error or "oops/error." Skip Osama bin Bombin'. What if there is a blackout on Election Day? It wouldn't have to be as big as the one that prostrated the entire Northeast last year, just one that encompasses key districts of a key state. How about a blown fuse in a polling place or an ice storm that takes out power lines in an election district? Voters may need candles — how Martha — but with a No. 2 pencil they could still vote at the designated time and place. The alternatives I can foresee would be worse: "do-overs" would be endlessly suspect, and "no-do-overs" would disenfranchise thousands.)
With a 0.1% error rate, we could be pretty confident that a candidate who won by, say, 2% in any election district really won. Even a 1% margin — the trigger for a manual recount in Florida in 2000 as I recall — would still be about 10 times the machines' error rate. But no matter what the spread, every vote would always be cross-checked by people. That should satisfy the "get it first" media and those — I confess I'm one — who want to know as soon as possible. Given the choice between speed and confidence, however, I choose the latter. And leave the Supremes — federal or state — out of it.
None of this is an absolute guarantee against fraud, much less various voter suppression machinations now running rampant all over the place. (I've lost count of the states and stories.) "We the species" are often too clever for our own good. But it could restore the bare modicum of trust essential to any functioning democracy: if you can make your way to the voting booth, your vote will be honestly counted.
posted by Glen |
7:30 PM |
Friday, October 22, 2004
Another Visit from Reality
Bob Herbert:
Dr. Gene Bolles spent two years as the chief of neurosurgery at the Landstuhl Regional Medical Center in Germany, which is where most of the soldiers wounded in Iraq are taken. Among his patients was Pfc. Jessica Lynch. In an interview posted this week on the Web site AlterNet.org, Dr. Bolles was asked: "What kind of cases did you treat in Landstuhl? And these were mostly kids, right?"
He said: "Well, I call them that since I'm 62 years old. And they were 18, 19, maybe 21. They all seemed young. Certainly younger than my children. As a neurosurgeon I mostly dealt with injuries to the brain, the spinal cord, or the spine itself. The injuries were all fairly horrific, anywhere from the loss of extremities, multiple extremities, to severe burns. It just goes on and on and on. ... As a doctor myself who has seen trauma throughout his career, I've never seen it to this degree. The numbers, the degree of injuries. It really kind of caught me off guard."
Pat Robertson (the June version, on Hardball)
And he said, Oh, no, our troops are, you know, so well protected, we don't have to worry about that.
posted by Glen |
1:11 PM |
Red Pill vs. Blue Pill
Jesus. Matt found a report from the Program for International Policy Attitudes (PIPA), which surveyed Bush supporters. Not surprisingly, most believed in the WMD, Saddam's intimate links to Al Qaeda, and all those other things.
But what dropped my jaw was the number of issues Bush backers thought Bush supported — when the exact opposite was true. By percentages from 51 to 74, they thought he backed the Kyoto treaty, the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty, and a very long list of others. "In all these cases, majorities of Bush supporters favor the positions they impute to Bush."
Who are these people?
Many, if not most of these issues — the Kyoto treaty being the best known (I hope) — were in the news before 9/11 and during the relative calm between the fall of Kandihar and the run-up to the war in Iraq. They made the front pages and the evening network news. The discussions may not have been good or in depth; the discussions may not have been read by most people, beyond the first 'graph. But the headlines and the sound-bites were absolutely clear: "Bush opposes..." You don't have to be a news junkie to pick up that central fact.
There are times I have to wonder if The Matrix is real, and Smith is just playing with us.
posted by Glen |
8:25 AM |
Thursday, October 21, 2004
Brief Note 2
The kitten you save may be your own.
posted by Glen |
7:04 PM |
Brief Note
I tend to filter out commercials (bad news for the people who pay for them). I just realized that George is going to give his "only morning TV interview" to Charles Gibson.
Will Gibson require meds for George or body armor for himself?
posted by Glen |
7:01 PM |
The Sum of All Pairs
Bush and Cheney are quite a pair. When they're not making stuff up out of whole cloth, they're accusing Kerry and Edwards of doing the exact things they themselves are doing — or not doing, as the case may be.
"The biggest threat we face now as a nation,'' he said, "is the possibility of terrorists' ending up in the middle of one of our cities with deadlier weapons than have ever before been used against us - biological agents or a nuclear weapon or a chemical weapon of some kind - to be able to threaten the lives of hundreds of thousands of Americans.''
"You have to get your mind around that concept," he added.
[…]
"John Kerry would lead you to believe he has the same kind of view that George Bush has, that he would be tough and aggressive," Mr. Cheney said. "I don't believe it. I don't think there's any evidence to support the proposition that he would, in fact, do it."
I assume he was trying to invoke The Sum of All Fears. Entertaining movie, and I'm sure it scared the bejeesus of a lot of people.
Problem is, as the New York Times noted in its endorsement of Kerry, "90 percent of the cargo unloaded every day in the nation's ports still goes uninspected." After three years… Not enough money, of course.
You also have to get your mind around the concept that Dick Cheney is an asshole.
posted by Glen |
3:33 PM |
Some Words from That Other Community
"Oh, no, we're not going to have any casualties."
— George Bush (via Pat Robertson)
By the time I saw it around noon yesterday, the story was rapidly spreading through the blogs. Today, it may be the quote heard 'round the world. Jim Capozzola thoughtfully provided a link to the transcript of Paula Zahn's peek through the looking glass with Pat Robertson, an apt guide if there ever was one. As shocking as the initial CNN excerpt was, it's no match for the whole thing: it's a mother lode of surreality.
ROBERTSON: I met with him down in Nashville before the Gulf War started. And he was the most self-assured man I ever met in my life.
You remember, Mark Twain said, he looks like a contended Christian with four aces. He was just sitting there, like, I'm on top of the world, and I warned him about this war. I had deep misgivings about this war, deep misgivings. And I was trying to say, Mr. President, you better prepare the American people for casualties.
Oh, no, we're not going to have any casualties. Well, I said, it's the way it's going to be. And so, it was messy. The lord told me it was going to be, A, a disaster and, B, messy. And before that, I had deep, in my spirit, I had deep misgivings about going into Iraq. [Emphasis added.]
To state the obvious, that remark — assuming that Robertson got it right — would be evidence that Bush is almost clinically insane: man of God or not, name a conflict in the Bible in which that was true. Unsurprisingly, the White House has denied that Bush ever said that.
A friend and I talked about it briefly last night. After she stopped "aghasting" (a new verb) she had two questions: (a) did Robertson get the quote right (could George have said, the casualties will be very low,, which may be delusional, but not certifiable)?; (b) why on Earth would he come out with that now?
Well, last night Andrew Sullivan answered both questions: Robertson said the same thing on Hardball back in June, albeit in a less crazy sounding form:
CAMPBELL BROWN (Guest host): I want to ask you how you feel about the war in Iraq. And if God is calling this war a disaster, does that mean that he is actually opposed to it?
PAT ROBERTSON: Well, I don't think God's opposed to the war, necessarily, but it was a danger sign. I felt very uneasy about it from the very get-go. Whenever I heard about it, I knew it was going to be trouble. I warned the president. I only met with him once. I said, You better prepare the American people for some serious casualties. And he said, Oh, no, our troops are, you know, so well protected, we don't have to worry about that.
As Andrew noted, the White House did not dispute Robertson's story then.
In other words, Robertson provided (babbled yesterday; in a saner sounding version in June) one more insider confirmation: Bush has been dangerously delusional from the beginning. He really did believe it was going to be a rose-petal-strewn cakewalk. But we knew that.
And we've been paying for that delusion ever since. (So have the Iraqis.) Troops were sent to Iraq without body armor. (Their families and friends have had to raise money to buy it for them.) The majority of Humvees are unarmored. As, as we know from the recent "mutiny" story during the past few days, people are sent into hazardous areas in trucks that are poorly maintained and break down frequently — and they're expected to go without armed escort. Why not? Nothing was going to go wrong.
More appalling, however, was the glimpse of Bush's zealots, personified by Robertson.
ZAHN: When you said: "The lord has just blessed him. I mean, he could make terrible mistakes and come out of it. It doesn't make any difference what he does, good or bad. God picks him up, because he's a man of prayer and God is blessing him."
Are you suggesting that God wants George W. Bush to win?
ROBERTSON: Well, I just think -- he loves him. I mean, George Bush is a man of prayer. He talks to the lord. He tries to get his direction from the lord.
[…]
ROBERTSON: I would never say somebody had to vote for anybody. That would be terrible. I haven't said that.
I just said, I think God's blessing him, and I think it's one of those things that, even if he stumbles and messes up -- and he's had his share of goofs and gaffes -- I just think God's blessing is on him. And you remember, I think the Chinese used to say, you know, it's the blessing of heaven on the emperor. And I think the blessing of heaven is on Bush. It's just the way it is.
And there we have it. It just doesn't matter. God's blessing is on the emperor. It's a very convenient arrangement.
posted by Glen |
1:33 PM |
Tuesday, October 19, 2004
Decisions, Decisions
I couldn't pass this up.
A new report from the Urban Institute estimates that, by even conservative counts, 65,000 lesbian and gay Americans are serving in the United States Armed Forces, on active duty, in the reserves and the National Guard.
The report, Gay Men and Lesbians in the U.S. Military, using estimates from the 2000 Census 2000 found that the length of service for gay men is equal to their heterosexual colleagues, while lesbians typically serve longer than their straight counterparts.
Every other article on Iraq refers to the troops we should have had at the beginning, what we need now, or what we will still need a year from now. What if all these people decided not just to tell, but yell? (Followed by the sound of Republican sphincters opening explosively.)
Just a thought.
posted by Glen |
7:05 PM |
Bobo in Wonderland
I've read Brook's collection of sentences three times, and I still can't believe it. It's not just unreality, it's almost an inversion of reality.
Kerry is "incompetent, crude and over-the-top" (Like the time he scared the crap out of Charles Gibson? Or the many, many times he couldn't put two sentences together?)
"Kerry is launching attacks that play up doubts voters have about him. Over the past few days, he has underscored the feeling that he will say or do anything to further his career." (Too many examples to count, and not just in the past few days.)
"[T]he insular Democratic world". (Perhaps he should have lunch with Ron Suskind)
The idea that Bush will bring back the draft is a "wild attack." (He will; we're running out of bodies and he's denying it too hard. But in classic Bushspeak, he'll call it "The Exciting Vacations Act" — an offer you just can't refuse!)
I don't comment about polls, but I'll make an exception. Bush was in New Jersey. Kerry was in Florida. This morning, Kerry's numbers had improved in both states. What were you saying about doubts?
posted by Glen |
1:26 PM |
Libel Suit Filed
Someone's following John Dean's advice.
PHILADELPHIA - A Vietnam veteran shown in a documentary criticizing Sen. John Kerry (news - web sites)'s anti-war activities filed a libel lawsuit against the movie's producer Monday, saying the film falsely calls the veteran a fraud and a liar.
Kenneth J. Campbell, now a professor at the University of Delaware, said in the suit that "Stolen Honor: Wounds That Never Heal" combines footage of him appearing at a 1971 war protest with narration that claims that many of the supposed veterans who took part in the event were later "discovered as frauds" who "never set foot on the battlefield, or left the comfort of the States, or even served in uniform."
The suit said viewers would be left with the perception that Campbell had lied about his military service.
Campbell attached copies of his military records to the lawsuit, showing that he received a Purple Heart and eight other medals, ribbons and decorations for his service in Vietnam.
Film producer Carlton Sherwood's company, Red White and Blue Productions, did not immediately return a call on Monday seeking comment.
Campbell also threatened legal action against the Sinclair Broadcast Group, an owner of 62 television stations that has announced that it intends to pre-empt regular programming to broadcast "Stolen Honor."
posted by Glen |
10:46 AM |
Let's Get Loud
Does somebody need a nap?
A high ranking Vatican official has denounced what he calls a powerful cultural, economic and political lobby that is drowning out the voice of the Pope - gay civil rights groups and organizations supporting a woman's right to choose.
Cardinal Renato Raffaele Martino, the former Papal Nuncio to the UN and now the president of the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace said the groups were "inspired mainly by anti-Christian prejudices".
How, exactly, does one "drown out the voice of the Pope"? Just asking.
posted by Glen |
6:43 AM |
Statistics
How many Iraqi civilians are dying? Who knows? The Pentagon has had no interest whatsoever in keeping a tally.
The day-to-day numbers, such as they are, have come from Iraq's Ministry of Health, which compiled them from hospital reports. Increasingly, the numbers are not, uh, helpful. The solution is simple: don't report them.
The deaths of Iraqis, particularly those of civilians, has become an increasingly delicate topic. Early this month, the Health Ministry, which had routinely provided casualty figures to journalists, stopped releasing them. Under a new policy that the government said would streamline the release of the figures - which were clearly an embarrassment to the government as well as to the Americans - only the Secretariat of the Council of Ministers is now allowed to do so.
I so look forward to the Secretariat's first news conference.
No wonder George and Allawi are such good friends. When reality becomes inconvenient, ban it.
posted by Glen |
6:18 AM |
Monday, October 18, 2004
Overdue updates in progress. And a new subtitle
Thanks to Matt Yglesias for the suggestion.
posted by Glen |
6:44 PM |
Sunday, October 17, 2004
An Anecdote
A cousin in Ohio sent e-mail, which I asked her permission to share (in part), because it really does provide a compare-and-contrast example between Bush's loyalty-oath vetted stage shows and Kerry rallies. I've deleted all names and some information about friends and neighbors.
I am totally bursting with enthusiasm! I was out running around all day (I mean from 9:30AM until 8:30PM) with a few cousins (C., K. & J.)--shopping etc. When I got home there was a phone message from a friend of mine here in the neighborhood, B..... Anyway, I didn't know whether to call him on a Sat night or not. So I checked my e-mail. Sure enough there was a message from B. to be there at the Marriott here in Dublin by 8:45 PM to GREET JOHN KERRY coming to Dublin Marriott to stay over, for Sunday AM he will be speaking at a church on the east side [of Columbus].
I got there, surprised! I didn't think there were that many Democrats in Dublin! [Dublin is a well-off suburb.] Ha!
But there was a crowd! [...] The secret service was out in full force, the media and cameras were rolling and the crowd was shouting--KERRY, KERRY, KERRY! And I started their chant - "HOPE IS ON THE WAY!" HOPE IS ON THE WAY! - HOPE IS ON THE WAY! It was soooooo much fun! And of course Kerry went down toward the other far end first where the media was, of course, and said a few words, then began shaking hands with everyone he could reach in the crowd! YEAH!!!!!
[B.] shook his hand above my head, and then Kerry came down and I shook his right hand, then again, I shook his left hand, and then I actually tapped my hand on his lapel and stated to him, God Bless You! We DO REALLY Need YOU! (Then of course the secret service woman was there to gently come between my hand and his lapel) - Hahahaha! But you talk about feeling pumped! It truly is a rush!
[...]
May God Bless - Say your prayers for our country that Kerry wins this election!
From voice-mail to hand-shaking in less than a half hour. Please let me know of any Bush or Cheney "rally" that allows such spontaneity.
I'm posting this because bloggers can be cynical, obsessed with poll numbers, and focused on the dark side of everything. (The first and last definitely include me). There's carping about the Kerry campaign (including some here), and all that media spin that Kerry is aloof, "real people can't relate to him," etc., etc. It's nice to be reminded how the non-blogging, non-media world sees things once in a while.
Thanks, cousin.
posted by Glen |
9:44 PM |
Sy Hersh
Via Blonde Sense, this video of Hersh's appearance at Berkley's conference on government secrecy. Viewing it requires Real Time. I don't know how well it will play over dial-up, and it's long. Try, if you have the time.
I've seen quotes, but it's not the same. As I watched, I got the sense that he knew so much and that he was so upset that even he couldn't articulate everything. And Hersh is one of the most consummately articulate individuals I can think of, for about thirty-five years. Infer what you will.
posted by Glen |
9:37 AM |
Saturday, October 16, 2004
Don't Forget Poland
WARSAW, Oct. 15 - Prime Minister Marek Belka of Poland narrowly survived a vote of confidence on Friday after telling Parliament, "We will not stay in Iraq an hour longer than is needed."
"Poland will reduce its contingent from the start of 2005 and will discuss subsequent reductions," Mr. Belka said during a speech to Parliament. But, he stressed, the withdrawal of some of the 2,500 Polish troops should not lead to instability in Iraq. Unfortunately, George, the Poles would like to forget you.
posted by Glen |
11:07 AM |
Sue the Bastards
It's infuriating that we've spent so much time on the Swift Boat Veterans for Lying Outrageously. It's infuriating that the major media took so long to do a thorough check of the SBVTs' claims. It's infuriating that the Kerry campaign let this group's claims acquire "legs" without crushing them like bugs in the first place. Detect a pattern?
I didn't see Nightline Thursday night.Kevin Drum did. The transcript leaves nothing to the imagination. Kevin adds,
Unbelievable. The SBVT folks, hoping to dig up dirt on Kerry, interviewed these villagers six months ago and have known the truth all along.
It wasn't just a case of differing recollections in the heat of the battle. They knew the truth. But they went ahead and told their lies anyway.
Uh, it's not only believable, it's absolutely predictable. (I know he was being ironic; so was I.)
So where are we? Every bit of documentary evidence I know of contradicts them. Every American witness I know of contradicts them. (That is, those witnesses who are not members of SBVT.) And now every living Vietnamese witness contradicts them. Detect a pattern?
The next question is what to do about it, if not now, then in the future.
When this sordid affair began, John Dean had a recommendation: sue the bastards.
The book doesn't mince words. It accuses Kerry of a number of crimes: fraud, lying before the Senate, filing false reports, dereliction of duty, desertion, and treason -- to mention only a few....
Not unlike the infamous Goldwater issue of Fact magazine [in 1965], John O'Neill's co-authored Unfit For Command reeks of actual malice. Whether Senator Kerry is elected or not, he should take these false charges to court in order to end this kind of campaigning. In so doing, he would protect not only himself, his campaign, and his legacy - he would also set a valuable precedent for future candidates, and do a public service by warding off future baseless attacks.
Fact said they were relying on statements they believed to be true; the court disagreed and Goldwater won. Kerry's case is much clearer: the SBVTs demonstrably knew their statements were false.
It's not the first time I've thought about this. The Clintons, individually or together, were accused of everything from drug running to murder; all lies. Though I thought he had cause, for a sitting president sue private citizens for libel or defamation, of course, would have been political dynamite. Given how close we are to the election, it is unlikely Kerry can act without creating a media storm that will overwhelm everything else. (I bitterly wish he'd acted in early August and exposed this group and their invidious connections; instead, that activity was largely confined to the blogs.) But as Dean suggested, on November 3rd, win or lose, the gloves should come off.
I have a libertarian distrust of libel and defamation suits, with roots that go back to John Peter Zenger. Too often, the guilty have used them to crush those who have disclosed the crimes of the powerful; for normal people, litigation costs would be crippling. As hateful as they are, I doubt I'd support a suit against Fred Phelps or David Duke; there would have to be something more material involved. But when the evidence clearly shows that a group is engaging in what would in other contexts be fraud, filing a false complaint, or perjury then it's time to stop it.
posted by Glen |
8:42 AM |
Friday, October 15, 2004
Pattern Recognition
Just another breathtaking moment in the Bush maladministration.
In his final debate with Sen. John Kerry on Wednesday night, President Bush reiterated his pledge to cut the nation's record budget deficit in half by the end of one more term in office.
"It requires pro-growth policies that grow our economy and fiscal sanity in the halls of Congress," he declared.
A day later, Bush's Treasury secretary, John Snow, told the halls of Congress that he's taking the extreme step of using government workers' pension money to avoid increased borrowing that would push the Bush administration past a $7.38 trillion debt ceiling.
In a dazzling display of fiscal sanity, Snow said in a letter to Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist of Tennessee that "it is imperative that the Congress take action to increase the debt limit by mid-November," which would be, as luck would have it, after the Nov. 2 election.
So let's recap: The Bush administration finds itself unable to operate within the boundaries of the highest debt ceiling in U.S. history, so its solution is to get by on other people's money until it can secure approval to run up even more debt.
That just about sums it up. Other people's blood. Other people's money. One could say it's a nasty habit.
And then there's that other habit: surrealism:
For his part, Josh Bolten, head of the White House Office of Management and Budget, said in a statement that the record $413 billion deficit is "a clear reflection of our strengthening economy and improving fiscal performance."
posted by Glen |
1:36 PM |
The War on Disbelief
Okay, there's that al-Zarqawi guy. You know, the one who's fond of cars that go boom and sharp objects in close proximity to people's throats. Via
Ezra we froze al-Zarqawi's assets — today.
As Ezra thoughtfully noted: ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME!
No wonder we can't find bin Laden.
posted by Glen |
1:10 PM |
Life with Father
The title is obvious, but no less than this.
LAS VEGAS - Sen. John Kerry's mention Wednesday of Vice President Dick Cheney's lesbian daughter drew rebukes from the Bush campaign yesterday and strongly mixed reactions from gays and lesbians.
"You saw a man who will do and say anything to get elected," Cheney told a rally in Florida. "And I am not just speaking as a father here, although I am a pretty angry father."
[...]
Although Cheney reacted angrily yesterday, he expressed thanks during his debate two weeks ago when Democrat John Edwards answered a question about same-sex unions, saying, "You can't have anything but respect for the fact that they [the Cheneys] are willing to talk about the fact that they have a gay daughter, the fact that they embrace her."
Asked a follow-up question, Cheney said only, "Let me simply thank the senator for the kind words he said about my family and our daughter."
Thank God he's not my father. I would never know when he would defend me, sell me out, or use me as a stage prop.
When Alan Keyes called Mary Cheney a "selfish hedonist," there was not one peep from "angry father" (or angry mother, for that matter). When John Edwards said kind words about the Cheneys' relationship with their daughter, Cheney thanked him. When John Kerry said that Mary Cheney has no problem about who she is (and she doesn't), Lynne and Dick go ballistic.
Does "angry father" expect anyone to take this threadbare production seriously? (Other than his party's knuckle-draggers, that is, and not even all of them.) It's enough to make a cat laugh.
I thought Kerry's response to the question was decent and tactful. (Maybe even overly tactful: there was a moment I thought he was going to fumble.) He pointed out what self-respecting gay people (and most of their families) already know: it's not a lifestyle; lifestyles are for Martha Stewart aficionados. Sexuality is simply an aspect of life. Removed from the religio-political sturm und drang, it's as consequential as being left-handed.
By choosing Mary Cheney as the human-face example, Kerry quietly pointed out that this is not a Democratic issue, it's a human issue — and some of those humans are Republicans. Implicitly, he also invited a compare-and-contrast with those Republicans who do have a problem with people like Mary Cheney: fine, family-valuing folks like Alan Keyes and "Man-Dog" Santorum.
Perhaps the Cheneys have a problem with the fact that Kerry doesn't have a problem with their daughter when so many of their party do.
Would that qualify as projection, or simple hypocrisy?
posted by Glen |
7:56 AM |
Thursday, October 14, 2004
Meanwhile, Back in Iraq
The Green Zone seems to be joining the rest of Baghdad
Two powerful nearly simultaneous explosions in Baghdad's fortified Green Zone killed at least seven people and wounded five others Thursday morning, according to early reports. The U.S. military said the attackers were suicide bombers.
posted by Glen |
8:20 AM |
Wednesday, October 13, 2004
Not quite a half-hour in and he's already unraveling, just less hysterically...
End of debate wrap-up: Bush didn't melt down. 'Twas a famous victory.
MORNING AFTER UPDATE: The "victory" remark was ironic.
posted by Glen |
9:26 PM |
Tuesday, October 12, 2004
I can't think of a suitable title fast enough. Just go here. Swallow liquids first.
posted by Glen |
6:47 PM |
e-Extortion
Finally.
A company which makes software that infiltrates users' computers and demands $30 to be removed has been targeted by US authorities.
The US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) is has asked a federal court to shut down the operations of Seismic Entertainment Productions and SmartBot.Net. The FTC action was initiated after it received a complaint from a Washington consumer group, the Center for Democracy and Technology. This is the first time that the FTC has taken action against a company that produces so-called "spyware".
The software exploits a flaw in Microsoft's Internet Explorer to gain access to a computer without the users' knowledge. The spyware interferes with the operation of the web browser, causes CD-ROM trays to slide open, slows down the computer or causes it to stop working entirely. The spyware then invokes a number of pop-up messages which urge consumers to buy programs called Spy Wiper or Spy Deleter to fix the problem for a fee of $30. Regardless of the veracity of the FTC's allegations, this tactic is not unknown among unethical spyware developers.
Please define an ethical spyware developer. Would that be someone places a bug in your home without your knowledge or consent, but doesn't charge to remove it? Yeah, that works.
Defining chutzpah, however, is easier,
Sanford Wallace, accused of infecting computers with software that causes flurries of pop-up ads and then trying to sell a $30 fix for the problem, said neither he nor his businesses have done anything wrong, and that he is being persecuted for his past Internet involvement.
His last "involvment" earned him the nickname "Spamford" Wallace. 'Nuff said.
Kevin Drum battled particularly vicious spyware on his mother's computer about a week ago. I don't know whether Wallace's clever little application technically qualifies as spyware, but if Kevin gets hold of him, "persecution" might be the last of Wallace's worries. A more accurate description of Wallace's activities would be extortion.
I don't know what can be done about it, technically. I have pop-up blockers, but the ads, like the Borg, seem to be adapting. As far as the perpetrators go, maybe law enforcement agents should deliberately set up groups of unprotected computers to become infected, trace the spyware back to the source, and arrest the SOBs.
Meanwhile, I hope Wallace goes to someplace very different than Camp Cupcake, and for a very long time.
posted by Glen |
1:07 PM |
Supply and Demand
Yesterday, there were several reports on the program to induce insurgents to turn in their arms. The deal was people got $1000 for a weapon worth $200 on the open market. There were similar "above-market" inducements for mortars, grenade launchers, even bullets.
If this latest attempt at a truce breaks down, too, haven't we just given them the money to buy four more weapons? Just asking.
UPDATE: from the Times
Indeed, at the gates of one of the weapons-disposal sites, the Iraqi security officers checked the identification card of an American reporter and then made him an offer.
"Do you want to buy the weapons inside?" he asked. "Just $150 for a Kalashnikov."
Was that even 24 hours?
posted by Glen |
8:06 AM |
Monday, October 11, 2004
Bush's War against America
Arthur Silber found one of those articles that just takes your breath away:
The Bush administration will delay major assaults on rebel-held cities in Iraq until after U.S. elections in November, say administration officials, mindful that large-scale military offensives could affect the U.S. presidential race.
Although American commanders in Iraq have been buoyed by recent successes in insurgent-held towns such as Samarra and Tall Afar, administration and Pentagon officials say they will not try to retake cities such as Fallujah and Ramadi -- where insurgents' grip is strongest and U.S. military casualties could be the greatest -- until after Americans vote in what is likely to be a close election.
"When this election's over, you'll see us move very vigorously," said one senior administration official involved in strategic planning, speaking on condition of anonymity.
"Once you're past the election, it changes the political ramifications" of a large-scale offensive, the official said. "We're not on hold right now. We're just not as aggressive."
Any delay in pacifying Iraq's most troublesome cities, however, could alter the dynamics of a different election -- the one in January, when Iraqis are to elect members of a national assembly.
The Los Angeles Times has a pretty intrusive registration policy, and Arthur has a longer extract; read it. He concludes:
[T]he only goal [Bush] genuinely cares about is his own reelection. Too many Americans being killed between now and November 2 and too much mayhem and bloodshed in Iraq might put that goal in jeopardy. So he delays major military action -- not for any legitimate tactical reason, but only because of concerns with his own personal ambition for a second term. But the tactics he obviously intends to implement once the election is over will only result in even more Americans being killed, and in even more mayhem and bloodshed.
God knows that Bush has plenty of competition for loathsomeness among American Presidents. Nonetheless, I cannot imagine that any President has ever been more dangerous, both in terms of our own security and for the general cause of peace in the world, or more personally contemptible.
I think I can guess Arthur's nominees.
The "senior official" assumes that Bush will win, unambiguously, on November 2nd. Now I'm going to say something as cynical as it comes. If Bush loses the election (and actually accepts the result; but that's another nightmare) he will provoke a bloodbath just as he leaves office, handing Kerry a conflagration for which he and the Democrats will be blamed by the Republicans for as long as it lasts. In short: Furious George's revenge.
I really don't like writing that, and I really hope I'm wrong. What's sad is that I think it's possible. Everything is about George: what he wants, what he likes, what benefits him. Forget God or ideology; screw Americans and Iraqis alike. The Times article is just one more confirmation.
For the first time in my life, I'm facing a president who truly scares me. I'm 53. Consider the competition.
posted by Glen |
8:33 AM |
Christopher Reeve
NEW YORK (Reuters) - "Superman" actor Christopher Reeve, paralyzed when he fell from a horse nine years ago, has died in a New York hospital of heart failure, his publicist said on Monday.
Reeve, 52, went into a coma on Saturday when he suffered a heart attack during treatment for an infected pressure wound and died in Northern Westchester Hospital on Sunday afternoon without regaining consciousness, publicist Wesley Combs told reporters.
Damn. Hard to say whether he would have ever walked again, but sheer willpower was not the problem.
UPDATE: Arthur has links to Reeve's foundations.
posted by Glen |
6:20 AM |
Sunday, October 10, 2004
New subtitle. I just heard an '80s club classic on the radio. Works for me.
posted by Glen |
4:39 PM |
The Debate, Belatedly
I watched the debate, talked with a friend for a few minutes, then crashed. (I seem to battling a cold and spent a lot of yesterday napping.) I saw virtually nothing of the spin. In some ways, it was a mercy. So, much delayed, some things that stood out, mixed with things I've seen since:VOLUME IS NOT A SUBSTITUTE FOR CONTENT!!!
Almost everyone has commented on it; why should I miss the fun? I squeaked off a quick post; right then I truly thought Bush was on his way to a China Syndrome meltdown. The two best takes I've seen since were Atrios (who compared him to a "bad American tourist in a foreign country") and Wonkette (who feared for her hearing). Oliver has kindly provided a clip for those who want to see Furious George in action one more time, and C-SPAN has the whole thing. ("Furious George" is not original, just apt.)
It wasn't just bad, it was painful and in some ways worse than the first debate. Affable Charlie Gibson — with whom millions share coffee in the morning — sat there like Bambi and watched Bush head toward him like a road-raging trucker. (Gibson's WTF expression was priceless.) I have to wonder how many people switched off right then. Those who did will have a nearly indelible image to take with them to the polls. So will those who didn't. We'll see if this gets as much media play as Howard Dean's "scream."
"It's just not credible when he [Kerry] talks about being fiscally conservative."
As if Bush is. I took some paint off the walls with that one. There must be an ad here: that two-second clip, with the words looped endlessly while the year-by-year debt and net deficit figures scroll by. The off-budget items should be included, too, as well as the per capita figures ("The cost to you..."), then the totals. It should probably be a 15-second spot, or the DNC could be accused of torture.
The Republic of Missouri
That was brilliant: "... if Missouri were a country, it would be the third largest country in the coalition, behind Great Britain and the United States..." It should be a standard item in every state Kerry and Edwards visit.
Okay, I'm a bit hot on this right now: my brother attended a funeral yesterday. The latest mobilization from Rochester, New York — one city in one state — is roughly equal to that of Australia's current contingent. Many states have suffered more casualties than almost all members of the coalition. I'm not denigrating other nations' deaths, but we are 90% of the coalition by any meaningful measure and Bush damned well knows it. As more members draw down or quietly steal away (which Kerry pointed out), we're going to be 91%, 92%, 95%.... (Don't forget Poland! Aleksander Kwasniewski feels deceived and Poland will likely withdraw its 2,500 troops early.) At what point will the coalition consist of the fifty states plus D.C., Puerto Rico (11 deaths, tied with Spain), American Samoa (2), Guam (1), and Marianas (1)? (But, hey, 54 is more than 30, right? We're gaining support!)
This should be hammered in a "your neighbors" kind of way. Kerry made an excellent first hit, but it should always be coupled with the constantly shifting/rewritten reasons for the war. The latest one, "gaming the oil for food" program, is the most ridiculous yet (but we have a few weeks to go). Using that "logic," should we have bombed Enron for gaming the energy market and the Stock Exchange?
(Parenthetically, I'm not wildly optimistic about Kerry's plan to get more nations involved. Under the so-called Pottery Barn rule and faced with domestic opposition, why should they? I think his only real bargaining chip would be to argue that if the chaos continues — or worse, spreads — oil could approach $100 a barrel, which they could afford no better than we. Yes, we're buying oil with lives and asking others to do the same. But that's always been true, whether you buy Bush's notion of "democracy dominoes" creating stability, or several more cynical theories.
(On the "character" level, however, I think our allies would feel confident that Kerry would not get bored and move on to the next shiny new war on a whim.)
Inspections and weapons
I was very happy to see Kerry bring up Hans Blix and the U.N. inspections. The point needs to be stressed as many times as necessary. Had Blix been allowed as much time as Kay and Duelfer, we would not be having this particular debate, nor the deaths, nor the debts (well, smaller ones...).
Another Kerry hit that got me cheering was Bush's failure to secure Iraq's conventional weapons. In short, Bush's attempt to do it on the cheap is killing people, ours and theirs. How about a bumpersticker? Iraq: the deal that was too good to be true.
At random
"Internets"? This is already one of the most-posted howlers. The drug threat from Canada has been ludicrous from the get-go and it gets worse with each rehashing. "School of thought"? Again, from Wonkette: "Where to begin...?"
For what it's worth, I like the town hall format. Sure, the participants are vetted six ways from Sunday, but it's the nearest we're going to get to hearing what people think is important, not jaded or self-impressed pundits. I was impressed by the sincerity and range of the questions. Better, if a candidate "responds" to a question by simply tossing off a perfunctory sentence, then reciting the next item on his or her playlist, it really looks bad. As long as the candidates never get the questions in advance and they're asked reasonably at random, I'll take what I can get.
Even if a couple of ringers get in — covert partisans, not the truly undecided or folks who are "leaning but persuadable" — that's the closest we come to having one candidate ask the other a direct question, albeit by proxy. Not necessarily a bad thing....
CYNICAL AFTERTHOUGHT: Is the world better off without Saddam Hussein? Yes. Would the world and the United States be better off without Bush? Also yes. But that only requires invading a voting booth.
posted by Glen |
4:18 PM |
Friday, October 08, 2004
Fiscal conservative??? Bwah-ha-ha-ha!!!!
Kerry looks better at this format than I ever believed...
posted by Glen |
9:57 PM |
Just 33 minutes in, if this goes on, Bush is toast. He's already unraveling.
posted by Glen |
9:32 PM |
Miracle Microbe
Something non-political, just because I like it. I was looking up info on why this year's flu vaccine is in such short supply. I came across a story about Serratia marcescens, the contaminant involved. It seems the bacterium was involved in a miracle 1263.
posted by Glen |
9:49 AM |
Krugman
As usual:
The point is that in the real world, as opposed to the political world, ignorance isn't strength. A leader who has the political power to pretend that he's infallible, and uses that power to avoid ever admitting mistakes, eventually makes mistakes so large that they can't be covered up. And that's what's happening to Mr. Bush.
posted by Glen |
7:39 AM |
Bremer Recants
I guess finding one horsehead in bed was enough. You can't get the stains out for nothin'.
But one thing was interesting:
... The military commanders believed we had enough American troops in Iraq and that having a larger American military presence would have been counterproductive because it would have alienated Iraqis. That was a reasonable point of view, and it may have been right. The truth is that we'll never know.
He's technically correct — because dissenting military commanders had been pushed out (ask General Shinseki). Yes men with stars on their shoulders are still yes men.
posted by Glen |
7:27 AM |
Thursday, October 07, 2004
Want to Play a Game?
Via Andrew Tobias (who needs permalinks), the effects of a 10-kiloton nuclear weapon on the zipcode of your choice. In context, Hiroshima was about 15-k.
By the way, all the port security stuff has been taken care of, right?
posted by Glen |
3:16 PM |
Reality Optional
This defies belief:
Vice President Dick Cheney asserted on Thursday that a report by the chief U.S. weapons inspector in Iraq, who found no evidence that Iraq produced weapons of mass destruction after 1991, justifies rather than undermines President Bush's decision to go to war.
The report shows that "delay, defer, wasn't an option," Cheney told a town-hall style meeting.
One more time: the choice was never between Condi's "mushroom cloud" or war. The sanctions had worked, as Hans Blix was on the verge of verifying (had Bush not yanked him out of Iraq), as David Kay verified months ago, and as Charles Duelfer re-verified this week. How many times need we reproduce the same results?
The really short answer to why we went to war? George wanted to. Everything else has been a waste of oxygen.
posted by Glen |
11:24 AM |
"We're so fucked."
Via Jo at Democratic Veteran. Jesus.
posted by Glen |
8:36 AM |
In Brief
Six years ago today, Matthew Sheppard was beaten and left tied to a wooden fencepost outside of Laramie, Wyoming. He died five days later.
I don't obsess about such things, but given the gay-bashing by and within the Republican Party — not 527 "allies," but the party itself — it's worth pointing out. Even the normally quiescent Log Cabin Republicans think so.
posted by Glen |
7:46 AM |
Tuesday, October 05, 2004
QUICK TAKE
Neither did well. Edwards did less well than I expected. Sorry to be contrarian, but there it is.
posted by Glen |
10:54 PM |
Round and Round She Goes…
Atrios found two items on CNN (one web, one on TV) where "officials" denied that Bremer asked for more troops. Problem is, yes he did. Atrios found a July 2003 article with the goods.
Now the White House is engaged. They simply refuse to say either way.
God just gave Edwards a gift.
posted by Glen |
3:14 PM |
Picture of the Day
Okay, I know he was being funny (or at least glib) but I really wish Andrew conjured a different image.
The format is God's gift to Daddy. They'll both be seated at a table, immediately allowing Cheney to do his assured, paternal, man-of-the-world schtick that makes me roll on my back and ask to have my tummy scratched. (Yes, I do think that Cheney is way sexier than Edwards. Not that you asked or anything.) ...
I'm going to need hours to get that one out of my head.
posted by Glen |
8:10 AM |
Never Mind
I was mistunderstood, says Donny Loose Lips. When I said yesterday there was no "strong, hard evidence" of Saddam-Al Qaida links, you misunderstood. There really, really were.
Also yesterday, Paul Bremer blurted out to a private group that the U.S. had made mistakes by not sending enough troops and not containing the violence and looting at the very beginning. Oh, but those words weren't meant for public consumption. What the general public needs to know it everything was well planned and things are going swimmingly.
And on the eve of Dick's big night, too. Looks like there were a couple of trips to the woodshed.
This could be funny if people weren't dying for it.
posted by Glen |
7:25 AM |
Monday, October 04, 2004
Loose Lips...
... sink ships. That's what they said during WWII. And nobody's got a looser pair than Rumsfeld.
WASHINGTON (CNN) -- Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld appeared Monday to back off earlier statements suggesting Iraqi dictator Saddam Hussein had links to al Qaeda.
He also conceded that U.S. intelligence was "wrong" in its conclusions that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction.
"Why the intelligence proved wrong, I'm not in a position to say. I simply don't know," Rumsfeld said in remarks to the Council on Foreign Relations in New York.
When asked about any connection between Saddam Hussein and al Qaeda, Rumsfeld said, "To my knowledge, I have not seen any strong, hard evidence that links the two." There was a petition some weeks back that called for Donny's resignation. Bet George and Dick wished they had signed it.
posted by Glen |
11:28 PM |
Sunday, October 03, 2004
Losing Tom Friedman
Back during that other quagmire, a member of Johnson administration reputedly said, "If we've lost Walter Cronkite...." And they had. Cronkite, whose voice may be second only to James Earl Jones in godlikeness pronounced Vietnam to be a fiasco shortly after the Tet Offensive.
I'm not comparing Tom Friedman to Walter Cronkite, qualitatively. He is, however, one of the "most quote-ables" of our era, and one most likely to be invited to talking-head fests. Accordingly, this is significant:
Sorry, I've been away writing a book. I'm back, so let's get right down to business: We're in trouble in Iraq.
I don't know what is salvageable there anymore. ...
Welcome back to reality. Hope you'll stay awhile.
posted by Glen |
11:40 PM |
Hard Work
Culture Ghost did a count. (I did one of my own, which was lost in a computer crash; his is more complete because he captured more variables.) "It's hard work. It's incredibly hard." "There's a lot of good people working hard." "There's a lot of really good people working hard to do so." "It's hard work." "And it's hard work." "I understand how hard it is." "I see on the TV screens how hard it is." "...so they can do the hard work." "It is hard work. It is hard work to go from...It's hard work to go...." "it's hard work to try to love her as best as I can..." "It is hard work." "Everybody knows it's hard work." "We've done a lot of hard work." Like others, I thought I might scream if I heard that phrase one more time.
The day after the debate, my brother called me at the office. He rarely does that.
Friends of his from college fell in love, married, and moved to a small town along the Ohio River; it was never a wealthy area in the state, and it's less so now. They have five kids; three are adopted. She quit work to home-school them. (Not for religious reasons, but for ones that frankly leave me in awe; I won't divulge.) They also care for his elderly parents and a mentally retarded brother, who live next door. They know everything about hard work, they don't complain, and they never, ever shirk.
In short, these are people you want as your neighbors, your friends, your kin.
Last December, he was mobilized as part of the Ohio Army National Guard and sent to Iraq. On September 18th, the fuel truck he was driving hit an improvised explosive device. He spent two weeks dying from the burns.
Their story is not unique — it may not even be the worst — but it's one I know something about. I should not be posting this, my brother should. But I'm the brother with a blog. I asked his permission to include a few details not already published in a local newspaper. Such as it is, here's my tribute.
As my brother and I talked, we also counted the cousins' sons, friends' sons, and in-laws' sons who were of draft age, or who soon will be. (From what I've seen, the sons' participations will be mandatory; the daughters', optional.) And yes, I think it will happen soon after November 2nd, should George be re-deified, precisely because the Republicans are protesting too much. The quagmire is already running out of bodies. Increasingly, the administration is less and less fussy about how they deliver them Send them without weapons into a combat zone? Whatever. There's hard work to be done.
I've been seething for two days. We are lectured from on high about hard work by a spoiled brat whose notion of it has been to remember whether the bottle opener or the coke spoon is passed left to right or right to left. Or remembering the phone numbers of family retainers who could bail him out of trouble. Whose friends — the "haves and the have mores" — will never risk anything harder than a paper cut.
My brother's friend (now singular) will know about hard work more acutely than ever. There's a lot of that going 'round right now. Four more years? I could bite through a wall.
posted by Glen |
11:30 PM |
Saturday, October 02, 2004
Free to Lie to You and Me
Now that Bush is not on the same stage as Kerry and thus not promptly challengeable, he once again feels free to make up any damned thing he likes.
COLUMBUS, Ohio Oct. 2, 2004 — President Bush on Saturday ridiculed what he called the "Kerry doctrine" as a dangerous outsourcing of America's security, seeking to poke a hole in Sen. John Kerry's debate performance with what advisers see as his rival's biggest miscue.
"When he laid out the Kerry doctrine, he said that America has to pass a global test before we can use American troops to defend ourselves," Bush said, drawing loud boos from a friendly crowd at a National Association of Home Builders meeting. "When our country is in danger, it is not the president's job to take an international poll, the president's job is to defend America."
In the debate, Kerry said he supported the right of a president to order a pre-emptive strike to protect the country but, he added, it must pass "the global test where your countrymen, your people understand fully why you're doing what you're doing, and you can prove to the world that you did it for legitimate reasons."
The "friendly crowd" would have been lobotomy loyalty-oath pre-vetted, of course.
Anyone who saw the debate or wants to check the transcript would find that ABC got it right in the third paragraph: Kerry said that a president of the United States should not run amuck, attacking countries at whim. He should have to make an honest case both to the world at large why it is necessary, and to those who will be doing the dying why they should consent to do so.
According to George, that's a very bad thing. I'm havin' a bad hair day. Let's bomb somebody. Ain't like nobody me and Karl know's gonna die.
posted by Glen |
5:15 PM |
Friday, October 01, 2004
Never Mind
There's a new tape from Al Qaida. Not that that matters. All the terrorists are in Iraq, right?
posted by Glen |
1:59 PM |
Post Debate Debate
If right-wing pundits are saying Kerry won, then he must have done better than I thought.
Morning after quarter-backing is easy, but I've seen several criticisms that Kerry didn't land a knock-out punch. Perhaps, but he did land good body blows: Osama bin Laden was the one who attacked us; Osama bin Laden was allowed to escape and remains at large and deadly as ever; Iraq was not then, but is now a center of terror; Iraq was not then, but is now a borderline failed state; sending troops into combat without body armor; several others.
There was one excellent knock-out opportunity during a one-minute extension:
Mr. Bush Thank you, sir. First of all, what my opponent wants you to forget is that he voted to authorize the use of force. And now says it's the wrong war at the wrong time at the wrong place.
I don't see how you can lead this country to succeed in Iraq if you say wrong war, wrong time, wrong place. What message does that send our troops? What messages does that send our allies? What message does that send the Iraqis?
No, the way to win this is to be steadfast and resolved and to follow through on the plan that I just outlined.
Mr. Lehrer Thirty seconds, Senator.
Mr. Kerry Yes, we have to be steadfast and resolved. And I am. And I will succeed for those troops now that we're there. We have to succeed. We can't leave a failed Iraq. But that doesn't mean it wasn't a mistake of judgment to go there and take the focus off of Osama bin Laden. It was. Now we can succeed. But I don't believe this president can. I think we need a president who has the credibility to bring the allies back to the table and to do what's necessary to make it so America isn't doing this alone.
Good as far as it goes, but I think Kerry should have said:
I voted to authorize Mr. Bush to use force — if necessary. I trusted him to use force — if necessary. Unfortunately, I was wrong to trust him. So were a lot of people.
When pressed to defend his original reason for going to war, Mr. Bush has hidden behind the vagaries of intelligence: that we thought but didn't know whether Saddam Hussein had WMD, and that we couldn't take a chance. Oh, and then there were all those mistakes.
What he hopes that you will forget is that we were gathering the necessary intelligence through Han Blix and his team. Had Mr. Bush allowed Blix the same amount of time given David Kay, he would have reached the same conclusion that Kay did: there were no WMD. The sanctions worked, and President Clinton's intelligent use of force in 1998 finished the job.
And we would have found all this out without the loss of a single life — American or Iraqi — or spending $200 billion dollars — so far. And we would have been free to pursue man who actually attacked us, Osama bin Laden.
That may not have fit into 30 seconds, but it would have been one of the killer punches Kerry needs to land, either in debates or on the stump. We trusted Bush to do one thing, he used that trust to do something very different, and a lot of people are paying the price. In short: betrayal.
In the context of last night's debate, it could have triggered one of Bush's infamous meltdowns. Moreover, it would have answered several charges Bush has used over and over during the campaign so far.
By the way, did anyone notice that Bush said "authorize the use of force," and not "voted for the war"? The latter is what he says during loyalty-oath vetted campaign stops. It's amazing what happens when the other guy is present and able to call you out.
posted by Glen |
8:37 AM |
|
 |
|
 |
 |